When to Start Your Novel

Both options can provide compelling openings for your novel, depending on the overall theme and tone you are aiming for. Here are some factors to consider when making your choice: 1. Emotional impact: The scene where the character is returning home for the first time since her father's death can bring a lot of emotions to the surface, allowing readers to connect with the character quickly. This can be effective if your novel focuses on the character's inner journey and emotional development. 2. Inciting incident: If the moment when the fiancee asks for permission to marry the character is the catalyst for the novel's central conflict, you might want to start with that scene. This can help to hook the readers early on by introducing them to the main storyline. 3. Atmosphere: Consider the atmosphere you want to create for your novel. Starting with the character returning home can evoke a sense of nostalgia and reflection. On the other hand, the scene where the character is at home waiting for her fiancee could create feelings of anticipation and tension. 4. Character development: What aspects of the character do you want to emphasize in the opening scene? If you want to show how much she's changed or how her priorities have shifted since her father's death, you could start with her returning home. Alternatively, if her relationship with her fiancee is central to the story, beginning with her waiting for his permission can quickly establish this dynamic. Ultimately, you should choose the opening scene that best aligns with the tone and themes of your novel. Experiment with both options and see which one best fits your story and allows you to introduce your main character and conflict in an engaging way.