Did Romeo Really Call Tybalt a Villain?

Tybalt is portrayed as a vindictive and impulsive character driven by his hot temper. He is a full-blooded Capulet, and bears a strong sense of loyalty to his family, and a sustained grudge against the Montagues. When Romeo crashes the Capulet’s party, Tybalt challenges him to a duel, believing that Romeo has dishonored the Capulets. His emotional intensity and hatred of the Montagues is apparent, with lines such as “What, drawn, and talk of peace? I hate the word/As I hate hell, all Montagues, and thee” (1.1.98-99). Romeo’s words would likely have an unexpected emotional effect on Tybalt. Romeo's declaration of love for Tybalt would be an unwelcome surprise and would cause Tybalt to feel confused and conflicted, as he holds such a deep-seated hatred for the Montagues. After all the times Tybalt expressed his strong disdain for Romeo, he would now have to re-evaluate his feelings, which could also be experienced as a sense of guilt. Though it is not stated explicitly, it is likely that his emotions would be most angry and confused, rather than softened by Romeo’s words. Romeo's words would likely make Mercutio feel frustrated, because it prevents the promised fight between Tybalt and Romeo that Mercutio has been anticipating. He might feel even more frustrated because Romeo is defying traditional expectations of feuding families. Mercutio might also feel insulted that Romeo would use such a disrespectful tactic to try to prevent the impending fight. In sum, Mercutio would likely feel a combination of frustration, anger, and resentment.